Breeding of Fuji Apples and Performance on JM Rootstocks

J. Soejima, H. Bessho1, S. Tsuchiya2, S. Komori3, K. Abe, and N. Kotoda

Apple Research Center, National Institute of Fruit Tree Science, Shimokuriyagawa, Morioka, Iwate, 020-01 JAPAN

1Current address: Yamanashi Fruit Tree Experiment Station, Manriki, Yamanashi.

2Current address: BRAIN, Toranomon 3-18-19, Minato-ku, Tokyo.

3Current address: Okinawa Subtropical Station, JIRCAS, Ishigaki, Okinawa.

Breeding of Fuji and Its Offspring

The Japanese apple industry developed following the importation of 75 cultivars from America in 1871. Ralls Janet and Jonathan had been the leading cultivars until the 1960s, when those cultivars were replaced by Starking Delicious and Fuji. Starking Delicious had the greatest production in the 1970s, but its production rapidly decreased after 1980 due to short shelf life. Fuji was introduced in 1962 and continues to increase its production. Fuji is now the leading cultivar and is grown on 48% of the apple orchard area in Japan. Fuji was selected from 787 hybrid seedlings of Ralls Janet and Delicious. Fuji fruits are medium to large size, red striped, firm, crisp, very sweet and very juicy. Fruit matures in early or mid-November and often develops water core. Trees are large, spreading, vigorous and productive. The original seedling tree of Fuji still produces fruits every year in the orchard of the Apple Research Center at Morioka.

Apple breeding in Japan is popular in each apple growing prefecture. Relatively large breeding programs are located in three regions, the Apple Research Center at Morioka, the Aomori Apple Experiment Station and the Nagano Fruit Tree Experiment Station. Fuji is regarded as one of the important parents for apple breeding. Long keeping ability and sweetness of Fuji have been inherited by its children and grandchildren (first generation and second generation seedlings). Extensive use of Fuji as a parent in apple breeding has resulted in several promising offspring in Japan (Tables 1 and 2). Some of these are described below.

Akibae. Originated in Nagano by K. Odagiri. From cross of Senshu x Tsugaru made in 1981; registered in 1993. It matures in early to mid-October at Morioka. Skin color is dark red. Flesh is crisp, juicy, sweet with moderate acidity. It is recommended as a good middle-season cultivar in Nagano prefecture.

Alps Otome. Originated in Nagano. It was found as a chance seedling of Fuji and introduced by K. Hatagoshi in 1964. It is a crab apple with sweet flavor and shows scab resistance. It matures in the middle of October.

Hacnine. Now the third leading cultivar in the Hokkaido area. Hacnine originated in Hokkaido by the Hokkaido Central Agricultural Experiment Station. From the cross of Fuji x Tsugaru made in 1971. Registered in 1984. It is triploid and trees are vigorous. It matures at the end of October. Fruit is very large, oblong, juicy and sweet with a mild, subacid flavor. This variety is adapted to a cool climate.

Hokuto. Originated from the Aomori Apple Experiment Station. From the cross of Fuji x Mutsu made in 1970. Registered in 1983. Triploid cultivar. Hokuto was 3.2% of Japanese apple production in 1995. It matures at the end of October. Quality of the fruit is excellent, and water core develops when fully matured. A shortcoming is the incidence of moldy core rot.

Kitaro. Originated in Morioka, Iwate, and was introduced by the Apple Research Center, National Institute of Fruit Tree Science (NIFTS) in 1997. From the cross of Fuji x Hatsuaki made in 1976. It matures in the middle of October with Delicious. Skin color is yellow, flesh is firm with excellent flavor. This cultivar, like Fuji, keeps very well in cold storage. Problems are preharvest drop and russets around the basin.

Senshu. Originated at the Akita Fruit Tree Experiment Station. From the cross of Toko x Fuji in 1966. Registered in 1980. It matures in early to mid-October. Skin color is bright striped red, flesh is crisp, juicy and the quality is excellent. This variety was 4.5% of Japanese apple production in 1990, but is decreasing now due to the cracking around the stalk cavity.

Shinano Sweet. Originated at the Nagano Fruit Tree Experiment Station. From the cross of Fuji x Tsugaru made in 1978. Registered in 1996. It matures in the middle of October. Skin of the fruit is smooth and red striped. Flesh is juicy and sweet. This cultivar is expected to be promising in Nagano prefecture.

Shinsekai. Originated at the Gunma Horticultural Experiment Station. From the cross of Fuji x Akagi made in 1971. Registered in 1988. Shinsekai is now a fifth leading cultivar in Gunma prefecture. It matures at the end of October. Fruit, covered with solid deep red, is sweet, but immature fruits remain astringent.

Apple Rootstock Breeding and Performance of Fuji on JM Series Rootstocks

A pendulous sport of Marubakaido (M. prunifolia Borkh. var. ringo Asami) has been the standard semi-vigorous rootstock for apples and is used in approximately 75% of apple orchards in Japan (Fukuda, 1994). Major advantages of Marubakaido are very good anchorage, early and heavy production, no burrknot production, crown rot resistance, woolly apple aphid (WAA) resistance, tolerance to wet soil conditions, and ease of propagation by hardwood cuttings. The shortcomings, however, are low virus tolerance and the formation of root suckers.

High density plantings using dwarfing rootstocks have increased since the 1970s in the less snowy areas of Japan. About 24% of apple orchards now have changed to high density plantings, mainly with M.26. Due to the troublesome problems of vegetative propagation of dwarfing rootstocks (e.g., M.9 and M.26, which do not propagate from cuttings), Japanese apple growers use these rootstocks as interstocks, grafted on rooted cuttings of Marubakaido. Trees are planted with the lower half of the interstock buried, allowing roots to grow from both stock components. This interstock system helps the trees grow well in a wide range of soils but makes Fuji trees grow too vigorously (Kikuchi, 1995).

An apple rootstock improvement program was started in 1972 at the Morioka Branch, Fruit Tree Research Station, now reorganized as the Apple Research Center, NIFTS. Main objectives of the program were: to develop excellent rootstocks that are able to 1) control tree size favorably, 2) resist diseases and pests such as violet root rot, crown rot, Valsa canker, WAA, 3) tolerate water-logged soils, and 4) propagate easily by hardwood cuttings (Bessho and Soejima, 1992).

A controlled cross of Marubakaido (Seishi) x M.9 was made in 1972. Over the next 11 years, initial screening of the seedlings continued at Morioka and 10 clones with the desirable characteristics of dwarfing (with high bark/wood ratio) and ease of propagation were selected in 1984. Beginning in 1985, these rootstock clones were distributed for field trials to several experiment stations in each apple growing district in Japan.

Based on orchard performance and observation of disease and pest resistance, JM 1, JM 7 and JM 8 were named and registered in 1996 for commercial release. JM 2 and JM 5 followed them in 1997. Application for registration under the Seeds and Seedlings Law of Japan to obtain plant breeder's right is now proceeding.

Characteristics of JM Series Rootstocks

Hardwood cutting. Over 90% of cuttings of JM 2 and JM 7, over 80% of JM 1 and JM 5, and over 70% of JM 8 survived when propagated as hardwood cuttings in the nursery. However, only 0-8% of M.9 EMLA and M.26 EMLA cuttings survived. Rooted cuttings of JM rootstocks grow 77-101 cm (30-40 inches) in height after six months in the nursery. Average trunk size of rooted cuttings was 6.1-7.0 mm (1/4 inch). This is ideal for grafting (Table 3).

Disease resistance. Five JM rootstocks were shown, in an excised twig assay, to be highly resistant to crown rot. Although JM 2 and 8 were resistant to apple chlorotic leaf spot virus (CLSV), JM 1, 5 and 7 were susceptible. Against ASPV and apple stem grooving virus (ASGV), those clones were resistant (Table 4).

Pest resistance. JM 1, 5, 7 and 8 showed resistance to woolly apple aphid. JM 2 was susceptible.

Dwarfing effect. Observations of trunk girth of Fuji trees over 15 seasons in the orchard at Morioka showed that JM 5 was very dwarfing; JM 1, 7 and 8 were dwarfing similar to M.9 EMLA; and JM 2 was semi-dwarfing (Table 5). Trees on JM 5, 7 and 8 showed typical overgrowth of the rootstocks (data not shown).

Precocity and yield. Trees of Fuji on JM 1, 7 and 8 had similar precocity to M.9 EMLA. Yield efficiency is used as a reliable predictor of productivity/unit area. Cumulative yield efficiency of Fuji was the highest with JM 7, and it was higher with JM 1, 5 and 8 than with M.9 EMLA or M.26 EMLA (Table 5).

Fruit quality. Fruit weight, red color development, soluble solids, titratable acidity as % malate, and flesh firmness were measured. Big differences were not found in these traits except for soluble solids content and flesh firmness among the fruits on selected rootstock clones. Soluble solids and flesh firmness were higher in JM 1, 5, 7 and 8 every year. Quality of Fuji fruits on JM 2 was similar to Marubakaido with slightly lower soluble solids content (Table 5).

In summary, JM series rootstock clones are very dwarfing to semi-dwarfing apple rootstocks and are propagated easily by hardwood cuttings. Our results suggest that resistance to several diseases and pests is better and the trees are more productive on the selected clones than they are on M.9 EMLA or M.26 EMLA. We regard these selected rootstocks as worthy replacements for M.9 and M.26 in Japan.

References

Bessho, H. and J. Soejima. 1992. Apple rootstock breeding for disease resistance. Compact Fruit Tree 25:65-72.

Fukuda, H. 1994. Apple. p. 23-27. In: Horticulture in Japan. K. Konishi et al. eds. Asakura Publishing. Tokyo.

Kikuchi, T. 1995. Systematic choice of apple orchard systems and the related training and pruning methods. J. Kor. Soc. Hort. Sci. 36:943-951.

 

 

Table 1. Description of major children (first generation seedlings) of Fuji bred in Japan.

         

Cultivar

(Reg. No.z)

Breeder

(Yeary)

Parentage

Season

Remarks

         

4-23

Aomori AES

(1975)

Fuji x Mahe 7

End Oct.

Red, juicy, slight core rot

Akita Gold

(3176)

Akita FTES

(1992)

Golden D. x Fuji

Mid. Oct.

Yellow, round-conical, firm

Akiyo

(5018)

S. Kudo

(1996)

Senshu x Fuji

End Oct.

Deep red, juicy, sweet

Alps Otome

K. Hatagoshi

(1964)

Fuji x unknown

Mid. Oct.

Crab, red, sweet, short shelf life

Beninomai (1992)

T. Murakami (1989)

Fuji x unknown

End Aug.

Red stripe, rather small

Chitose Queen

(4297)

T. Yamashita (1995)

Fuji x unknown

Early Sept.

Yellow, rather small

Gunma Meigetsu

(2816)

Gunma HES (1991)

Akagi x Fuji

Early Nov.

Yellow, sweet, water core

Hacnine (1237)

Hokkaido CAES (1986)

Fuji x Tsugaru

Mid. Oct.

Very large, red stripe, juicy, triploid

Hida

(930)

T. Sunahara (1985)

Fuji x Orin

Mid. Oct.

Red stripe, sweet

Himekami (931)

Apple RC, NIFTS (1985)

Fuji x Jonathan

End Sept.

Oblong, pinkish red, water core

Hokuto

(368)

Aomori AES (1983)

Fuji x Mutsu

End Oct.

Very large, juicy, sweet, core rot, triploid

Hozuri (5019)

Fukushima FTES (1996)

Fuji x unknown

Early Nov.

Red stripe, juicy, subacid

Iwakami (932)

Apple RC, NIFTS (1985)

Fuji x Jonathan

End Sept.

Red stripe, subacid

Kitaro (applied for)

Apple RC, NIFTS

Fuji x Hatsuaki

Mid. Oct.

Yellow, firm, keeps well, preharvest drop

 

Kizashi (2933)

Apple RC, NIFTS (1991)

Gala x Fuji

End Aug.

Small, deep red, crisp, acid

Menkoihime (4478)

T. Murakami (1995)

Raritan x Fuji

End Aug.

Red stripe

Narihoko (926)

T. Narita (1985)

Golden D. x Fuji

Early Nov.

Green yellow, subacid

Natsunishiki (2635)

S. Sakurai (1991)

Fuji x American S.P.

End Aug.

Red stripe, sweet

Nishina (2355)

H. Ozawa (1990)

Fuji x Raritan

Mid Aug.

Deep red stripe, coarse, acid

North Queen (1864)

Hokkaido CAES (1989)

Fuji x Tsugaru

Early Oct.

Large, red, juicy

Seimei

(4479)

Y. Ito (1995)

Golden D. x Fuji

Mid Oct.

Red stripe, juicy, sweet

Senshu

(42)

Akita FTES (1980)

Toko x Fuji

Early Oct.

Red stripe, excellent flavor, cracking

Shinano Sweet

(5139)

Nagano FTES (1996)

Fuji x Tsugaru

Mid Oct.

Red stripe, juicy, sweet

Shinsekai (1564)

Gunma HES (1988)

Fuji x Akagi

End Oct.

Deep red, sweet, slightly coarse

Slimred (4298)

Gunma HES (1995)

Fuji x Akagi

Early Nov.

Red stripe, small, juicy

Takashima (3303)

S. Komatsu (1992)

Fuji x unknown

Mid. Oct.

Red stripe, juicy, sweet

zRegistration number under the Seeds and Seedlings Law in Japan.

yYear of registration or introduction.

 

 

 

 

 

Table 2. Description of major grandchildren (second generation seedlings) of Fuji bred in Japan.

         

Cultivar

(Reg. No.z)

Breeder

(Yeary)

Parentage

Season

Remarks

         

Akibae

(3411)

K. Odagiri

(1993)

Senshu x Tsugaru

Mid-Oct.

Dark red, crisp, juicy, subacid

         

Kanki

(3304)

S. Kudo

(1992)

Senshu x Tsugaru

Early Oct.

Dark red, crisp, juicy, subacid

         

Miki Life

(3231)

S. Kudo

(1992)

Senshu x Tsugaru

Early Sept.

Red stripe, crisp, juicy

zRegistration number under the Seeds and Seedlings Law in Japan.

yYear of registration or introduction.

 

 

Table 3. Growth of rooted cuttings after 5 months in the nurseryz.

       

Rootstock

Number of cuttings which survived

(%)

Height

(cm)

Diametery

(mm)

       

JM 1

85

102

7.1

JM 2

97

82

6.4

JM 5

82

73

6.1

JM 7

94

87

6.8

JM 8

74

76

6.7

       

M.9 EMLA

0

--

--

M.26 EMLA

7

29

3.1

zMean of 1995 to 1996.

yMeasured at 20 cm above the ground.

 

 

 

Table 4. Relative pest and disease resistance of five JM and Malling apple rootstock clonesz.

           

Rootstock

WAA

Crown rot

P. cactorum

P. cambivora

CLSV

SPV

           

JM 1

VR

VR

M

S

R

JM 2

VS

M

R

R

R

JM 5

VR

R

R

S

R

JM 7

VR

VR

M

S

R

JM 8

VR

VR

M

R

R

M.9 EMLA

VS

S

VS

R

R

M.26 EMLA

VS

VS

VS

R

R

zRating system: VR=very resistant; R=resistant; M=intermediate; S=susceptible;

VS=very susceptible.

 

Table 5. Tree size, yield efficiency and selected fruit quality traits for 14-year-old Fuji with seven apple rootstock clones.

             

 

 

Rootstock

 

Trunk girth (cm)

Cumulative yield/tree (kg)

Yield efficiency (kg/cm2 TCA)

Fruit weightz

(g)

 

Soluble solidsz (%)

Flesh firmnessz

(kg)

             

JM 1

41.7by

338c

2.44c

264

15.3c

16.8de

JM 2

53.2d

295b

1.31a

226

14.1a

15.9bc

JM 5

30.0a

172a

2.40c

254

16.2e

17.1e

JM 7

43.1bc

401e

2.71d

267

15.9d

16.5d

JM 8

40.5b

327c

2.51c

257

15.2c

16.8de

M.9 EMLA

46.3c

337c

1.97b

256

14.4ab

15.9bc

M.26 EMLA

59.3e

373d

1.33a

262

14.3ab

15.5ab

zMean of 1993 to 1996.

yMeans followed by the same letter are not significantly different (P=0.05, n=5).